Much of the composition makes use of the word
“rhetoric.” That from the ‘70s and ‘80s often equates rhetoric with compositional
conventions. Transitions, attention to detail, topic sentences, etc.,
constitute the elements of rhetoric, and students are meant to learn good
rhetoric by mimicking the rhetorical conventions visible in film. Most ‘90s and
post-2000 scholars use the term in a deeper sense. For them, compositional and
organizational coherence are an element of rhetoric, but rhetoric more
importantly implies a rhetor-audience relationship (here, film-viewer) where
the former is attempting to persuade, inform, or in some way influence the latter.
Many of the more recent scholars, too, insist on a rhetorical consciousness of
the discursive situation, upholding Berlin’s assertion that “for a postmodern
rhetoric, the writer and reader or the speaker and listener must likewise be
aware that the subject or producer of discourse is a construction, a
fabrication, established through the devices of signifying practices”. In the
study of film and composition, modern perspectives like Berlin’s suggest that
especial attention must be paid to the medium of film and its particular
rhetorical devices (“signifying practices”) that attempt to gain credibility
among audiences, while stirring their emotions and advancing ideological
premises. Composition scholars have pointed out the rhetorical potency of film,
but—despite the efforts of Costanzo, the neo-Aristotelians of the ‘70s, David
Blakesley, and others—the body of work exploring heuristics or specific
rhetorical vocabulary, in order to analyze how films persuade and inform,
remains limited. Here, they wanted to work toward a rhetoric and pedagogy that
seeked to fill this void, one that begins by retooling the syllogistic
justification behind much of the ‘70s composition scholarship. Employing a more
complex idea of rhetoric, we can claim that X) students are at least familiar
with film, and will continue to watch films in- and outside the classroom, Y)
that films are rhetorically constructed and use rhetorical devices parallel to,
but perhaps formally divergent from, other
33 persuasive texts, and Z) that we can therefore teach film as part of
an effort to instill learners with a comprehensive rhetorical consciousness
that extends beyond both the written text and the classroom.
No comments:
Post a Comment